The Two Orients for Greek Writers

Edit

Article

by Takuji Abe
published on 22 February 2012

India was subdued by Darius I and incorporated into the vast Persian Empire at the end of the sixth century. This conquest stimulated the interest of Greeks living in Persian Asia Minor, such as Scylax, Hecataeus, Herodotus and Ctesias, whose accounts of India are known to us. The aim of this paper is to examine those accounts, and bring forward the authors’ views of India, the Persian Empire, and the world.

The investigation, which focuses mainly on Herodotus and Ctesias due to the relative size and scope of their surviving works, points to the following: Ctesias’ Indica was based on more direct and personal experience than Herodotus’ logos, since Ctesias stayed at the Persian court for a substantial length of time and likely had ample opportunity to experience aspects of Indian culture first hand. They had a similar image of India, but Ctesias’ description of Indian tribes is more fantastical in nature than that of Herodotus’, in spite of his having more direct experience. I subsequently hypothesize that Ctesias had a greater tendency to accept information which sounded ‘irrational’ to him, due to his prior knowledge of Indian ‘marvels’. Lastly, the absence of a mortal king, which is a clue to understanding of the historiography of Herodotus and Ctesias, gave readers the impression that India was ‘a nation without history.’



Written by , linked by Jan van der Crabben, published 22 February 2012. Source URL: http://repository.kulib.kyoto-u.ac.jp/dspace/bitstream/2433/151359/1/aak_11_1.pdf.

Disclaimer: Ancient History Encyclopedia claims no authorship, intellectual property, or copyright on the material below. It is used solely for non-profit educational purposes, and none of the data is stored on our servers. If you want this content to be removed from the site, please contact us.

Related Books

 

Comments

comments powered by Disqus

Advertisement

Newsletter

Sign up for our newsletter:

Recommended

Advertisement

Sponsors
Many thanks to the companies who are kindly helping us:
         
Partners